Pin Magic vs RecurPost

By Muhammad Ali Qureshi · Updated 23 October 2026 · 6 min read

Short answer: RecurPost is a scheduler built around content libraries that repeat over time. Pin Magic is built to create the pins and the blog images: paste a post link, get 10+ pins, and use the Extension for WordPress images and internal links. If you have plenty of pins and want them to keep going out, pick RecurPost. If you are short of pins, pick Pin Magic. Together they cover both halves.

Quick comparison: Pin Magic vs RecurPost

Pin Magic does not schedule or recycle. It makes the pins, and you publish them with any tool. For a wider view of scheduling tools, read Internal Linking Tools for WordPress Compared.

What is RecurPost?

RecurPost is a social media scheduler. Its best-known idea is the content library: you save posts in groups, and the tool sends them out again and again on a schedule. That suits evergreen content that stays useful for months.

It works across several social networks, and Pinterest is one of them. So it is a publishing and recycling tool. It needs pins to publish. Pin Magic is the tool that helps you make those pins in the first place, starting from the post you already wrote.

Where each tool is strong

RecurPost is strong at

• Libraries of evergreen content that repeat without you rebuilding the queue each week.
• One place to schedule for several networks, not only Pinterest.
• A simple way to keep an old back catalogue visible without daily effort.
• Useful for small teams who want a steady, hands-off posting rhythm.

Pin Magic is strong at

• Paste a post link in Studio and get 10+ different pins built on 100+ templates.
• Your own photos, colours and fonts, exported at 1000 x 1500 PNG.
• The Extension makes blog images with Flow, inserts them into WordPress and adds internal links.
• One flat price, with a lifetime option, and no limit tied to how many posts you queue.

What to keep in mind about RecurPost

Recycling and creating are different jobs. Here is what to watch for with each.

• Recycling repeats the same pin. Pinterest rewards new images, so a pin that is reposted unchanged may do less each time. See fresh pins on Pinterest.
• RecurPost needs pin designs to exist already. It does not build your pins or blog images from a post link.
• Pin Magic does not schedule or recycle. You export the PNGs and publish them yourself or through a scheduler, including RecurPost.
• Pin Magic has no analytics. Use Pinterest Analytics or your scheduler to see what works.

Recycling old pins vs making fresh ones

Recycling feels efficient. You do the work once and the tool repeats it. For Pinterest, though, a repeated pin is the same image with the same text. Pinterest tends to favour new creative, even for an old URL.

A better pattern is to recycle the post, not the pin. Take one evergreen post and make several new pins for it, each with a different photo, headline and layout. Studio does that in minutes. Then let a scheduler such as RecurPost spread those pins out over weeks. Read how often to post on Pinterest for realistic volumes, and how to create Pinterest pins with AI for the creation side.

Pricing

Pin Magic: the Studio + Extension bundle is $10/month or $70/year, and the Extension alone is $5/month or $35/year. A one-time lifetime deal for the bundle costs $100. See pricing and the lifetime deal for live prices.

RecurPost: it sells subscription plans that differ by how many social accounts and features you get. Plans change, so check the RecurPost site. You do not need to cancel it to try Pin Magic, because Pin Magic only creates pins.

Which one should you choose?

Choose Pin Magic if

• You have many posts but few pins and spend hours designing.
• You want several different pins per post, not one pin repeated.
• You use WordPress and want blog images and internal links done for you.
• You prefer a low flat price or a one-time payment.

Choose RecurPost if

• You already have a stock of pins and want them to keep publishing.
• You want one scheduler for several social networks.
• You like the idea of evergreen libraries that refill your queue.

Use both if

• You want a library that never runs dry. Make new pins in Pin Magic, then load them into a RecurPost library.

How to use Pin Magic with RecurPost

A simple workflow that keeps recycled content fresh:

1. Choose an evergreen post that still gets traffic. Check its keywords with Pinterest keyword research.
2. Paste the link into Pin Magic Studio and generate 10+ pins.
3. Change photos, colours and text so the pins look clearly different. Export 1000 x 1500 PNG files.
4. Write titles and descriptions with the free title generator and description generator.
5. Add the pins to a RecurPost library and set a slow schedule. Repeat with the next evergreen post.

For a broader look at automation, read best Pinterest automation tools and Pinterest automation best practices. If you compare other recycling schedulers, see Pin Magic vs SocialBee.

Frequently asked questions

We describe RecurPost in general terms because its plans and features change often. Check the RecurPost website for its current features and prices before you decide.

More Pin Magic comparisons

Pinterest-focused tools

Social media management suites

Design tools